Revolutionizing Pakistan’s Foreign Policy: Power, Pragmatism, and Prosperity

By Iqra Nasir

• Strategic Alignment: Forge alliances with precision to bolster security and economic prowess.
• Economic Sovereignty: Cultivate internal strength while leveraging global partnerships for sustainable growth.
• Regional Diplomacy: Navigate complex geopolitics with finesse, prioritizing peace and stability.
• Multifaceted Alliances: Establish diverse partnerships to fortify national autonomy and influence.

The formative era of Pakistan’s foreign policy, which lasted from 1947 to the early 1970s, offers valuable insights for today’s policymakers. This period was characterized by crucial strategic decisions, important alliances, and significant crises that continue to shape Pakistan’s global position. By closely studying these early years, one can gain a deeper understanding of the triumphs and setbacks that have influenced the nation’s diplomatic path.

One of the key lessons from early foreign policy is to realize the ideological foundations and a well-defined national identity of the respective state. Pakistan was founded on the vision of Muhammad Ali Jinnah, who aimed to create a nation where Muslims could freely practice their religion.

Pakistan Denounces US ‘Political Exploitation’ in Sanctions Against Missile Program Allie

This ideological basis was intended to be reflected in foreign policy, attracting support from other Muslim-majority countries and positioning Pakistan as a leader in the Muslim world. However, striking a balance between this ideological stance and pragmatic statecraft proved to be a complex undertaking. While projecting itself as a champion of Islamic solidarity, Pakistan also had to navigate the geopolitical realities of the Cold War era. The lesson here is that while ideology holds importance, it must be harmonized with practical considerations to achieve a well-rounded and effective foreign policy.

Pakistan’s Economic Diplomacy and Self-Sufficiency:

Pakistan’s foreign policy in its initial stages placed great emphasis on economic diplomacy. Faced with significant economic hurdles such as the need for industrialization and infrastructure development, Pakistan actively sought foreign aid and investment to stabilize its economy. The pursuit of economic assistance from the United States and later from China emphasized the vital role of foreign aid in fostering economic growth.

Nevertheless, this reliance on external support also underscored the importance of self-sufficiency. The key lesson learned here is that while foreign aid can offer crucial assistance, sustainable economic development necessitates the cultivation of internal capabilities. Moreover, developing domestic industries, enhancing education, and investing in technology are also essential for attaining long-term economic independence.

Pakistan’s foreign policy is well past its shelf life. Here’s why it needs a paradigm shift

Pakistan’s foreign policy was shaped early on by its decision to align with the West, especially the United States. This alignment was influenced by several key factors. Pakistan sought protection against what it perceived as a significant threat from India. The violent partition of British India in 1947, followed by conflicts in 1948 and 1965, solidified this threat perception.

The fear of Indian military superiority and the need for a strong ally to counterbalance India’s influence played a crucial role in Pakistan’s decision to align with the West. The fledgling Pakistani economy required substantial financial assistance for development and stabilization. The United States, with its significant economic resources, emerged as a vital partner. American economic aid helped Pakistan build infrastructure, industrialize, and modernize its military.

As the Cold War escalated, Pakistan positioned itself as a frontline state against communism. This strategic positioning aimed to attract military and economic aid from the United States, which sought to contain Soviet influence in Asia. By joining Western alliances such as SEATO (Southeast Asia Treaty Organization) and CENTO (Central Treaty Organization), Pakistan aimed to secure its borders and receive necessary military assistance.

Crossroads of Change: Redesigning Alliances for Pakistan’s Strategic Growth

While this alignment brought substantial military and economic assistance, it also led to Pakistan’s involvement in conflicts that did not always align with its national interests, such as participation in US-led initiatives in the Middle East and later in Afghanistan. The long-term implications included dependency on Western aid and periodic strain in US-Pakistan relations, especially when American and Pakistani interests diverged.

The Kashmir Factor:

The Kashmir struggle has been a foundation of Pakistan’s international strategy since the division of the subcontinent. The main Indo-Pak battle in 1948, resulting in the UN-mediated truce and the establishment of the Line of Control (LoC), set up a prolonged and contentious debate. Pakistan’s endeavors to internationalize the Kashmir issue and gain support from worldwide powers and the UN have met with limited success, mainly due to the complexities of international politics and India’s growing influence.

One of the lessons learned is the danger of relying too much on one ally. Pakistan was vulnerable because of its strong reliance on the United States. Although Pakistan’s military capabilities were enhanced by US aid, over-dependence resulted from the program. Changes in US foreign policy caused the relationship to fluctuate; this was especially clear in 1998 when sanctions were placed by the US in response to Pakistan’s nuclear tests. This emphasized the necessity of a multifaceted foreign policy that lessens reliance on any one country.

Pakistan sought to unite the Muslim world and gain support against India by emphasizing its Islamic identity in its foreign policy. But occasionally, practical national interests clashed with this ideological stance. For example, in the 1971 Bangladesh Liberation War, Pakistan did not expect Muslim countries to support it.

The emphasis on the Kashmir conflict and the adversarial relationship with India have often overshadowed the broader need for regional stability. Engaging in multiple conflicts with India has diverted resources and attention from other critical areas, such as economic development and internal stability. This underscores the importance of pursuing diplomatic avenues and confidence-building measures to foster regional peace.

While alliances with powerful nations can provide immediate benefits, they must be strategically managed. Pakistan’s experience highlights the importance of balancing the quest for aid with the preservation of national autonomy. Diversifying alliances, such as strengthening ties with China and other regional powers, can provide a counterbalance to over-reliance on a single ally.

Analyzing the Impact

The monetary aid and military help from the US assisted Pakistan in building its tactical foundation and economy to some extent. Nonetheless, the long-term financial effect was mixed. While short-term gains were significant, dependence on foreign aid often delayed essential economic reforms and led to periods of financial instability when aid was reduced.

Strategically, Pakistan’s international strategy choices during this developmental stage shaped its global image and political relations. The close partnership with the US during the Cold War era positioned Pakistan as a central player in South Asia but also made it a target for Soviet aggression. The relationship with China, which began during the 1960s, proved to be an essential masterstroke, providing a balance to both India and US influences.

The developmental period of Pakistan’s international strategy provides valuable lessons for contemporary policymakers. It highlights the significance of a balanced and practical approach that focuses on public interests while navigating global power dynamics. Reducing reliance on a single partner by fostering relationships with different countries can enhance national security and economic stability.

Pursuing peace and stability in the region can provide a conducive environment for economic growth and development. By learning from the past, Pakistan needs to develop an international strategy that addresses current challenges as well as anticipates future opportunities and risks. The early stages offer a guide, highlighting the importance of flexibility, strategic thinking, and the pursuit of a balanced approach in the complex field of international relations.