- U.S. mobility has collapsed: only 7.8% of Americans moved homes in 2023, the lowest rate since 1948.
- Job switching has dropped from 2.8% per month in the 1990s to 2.3% in the 2020s, signaling a stagnant labor market.
- In contrast, Chinese and Russians are actively buying homes, villas, SUVs, and changing jobs more frequently.
- Europe, despite aging demographics, shows more cross-border job mobility among younger professionals than the U.S.
For generations, the American dream was synonymous with mobility—packing up, moving across states, trading up in jobs, and striving for a better life. But today, that momentum is faltering. Americans are literally stuck in place.
Stagnant Mobility, Slowing Growth
Residential mobility in the U.S. has dropped to just 7.8% in 2023—the lowest level since records began in 1948 (compared to nearly 20% in the 1950s and 1960s). The decline from 9.8% in 2019 underscores the dramatic slowdown in people relocating even within counties, where moves have plunged nearly 47% over the last three decades.
“The America that once prided itself on dynamism—people chasing opportunities and industries across the map—has grown sluggish,” said Dr. Karen Whitfield, a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council. “That loss of motion doesn’t just hurt individual families; it hurts the nation’s overall productivity and global competitiveness.”
Trump, Putin End Alaska Summit Without Ukraine Deal Despite Spectacle of Red-Carpet Welcome
Economists like Chang-Tai Hsieh of the University of Chicago warn this immobility is dragging on U.S. GDP growth. Historically, from 1964 to 2009, rising mobility contributed significantly to expansion, but the pattern appears broken today.
READ MORE: Trump, Putin End Alaska Summit Without Ukraine Deal Despite Spectacle of Red-Carpet Welcome
The job-switching rate, another marker of labor dynamism, has fallen from around 2.8% per month in the late 1990s to roughly 2.3% in the 2020s. This suggests fewer workers are willing—or able—to pursue new opportunities that might bring higher wages or new skills.
Global Contrast: China, Russia, and Europe
While America slows down, the rest of the world keeps moving.
-
China: Middle-class buyers are purchasing second homes, villas, and SUVs, fueling a sense of upward mobility and economic confidence.
-
Russia: Despite sanctions, its job and housing market remains surprisingly fluid, with citizens still relocating and purchasing property at higher rates than Americans.
-
Europe: Once bound by cultural and linguistic barriers, it is seeing modest gains. Yet by 2050, its retiree-to-worker ratio will nearly double, threatening growth.
Europe’s GDP per capita is projected to rise from $37,800 to $50,950 by 2030, while China is expected to overtake the U.S. as the world’s largest economy that same decade.
ALSO READ: Live Updates: Trump Says There Is ‘No Deal’ on Ukraine After Summit With Putin
“The irony,” said Dr. Matthew Reyes, a foreign policy expert at Georgetown University, “is that America, once the benchmark for upward mobility, is now being overtaken in movement by societies we long considered static.”
Side-by-Side: U.S. vs. the World
| Indicator (2023–2030 outlook) | United States (current) | Trump’s MAGA vision (projected) | China | Russia | Europe (EU avg) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Residential Mobility | 7.8% (record low) | 11–12% (target by 2030) | 14%+ | ~13% | ~10% |
| GDP Growth (avg per year) | 2.1% | 3.5–4% with MAGA reforms | 4.7% | 2.2% | 1.6% |
| Job Creation (next decade) | ~12 million | 20–22 million (reshoring, infra) | ~80M | ~7M | ~14M |
| Median Wage Growth (2030 proj.) | 2% annually | 4–5% under MAGA policies | 5% | 3% | 2% |
| Homeownership Growth | Stagnant (~65%) | 70–72% goal by 2030 | Rising | Stable | Declining |
This table highlights a core argument of Trump’s supporters: a bold, pro-growth agenda is the only way to reverse U.S. stagnation and keep America competitive.
U.S. Structural Challenges
Behind the numbers are real human stories. Workers like Josue Leon, who mailed out over 200 job applications, lived with his partner’s family, and declined relocation because of low pay, personify the immobility crisis. Mortgage “golden handcuffs” keep homeowners stuck, companies slash relocation assistance, and young adults who fail to land strong jobs early often fall behind for a decade or more.
A frozen housing market compounds the paralysis: retirees can’t downsize, families can’t trade up, and first-time buyers are locked out. The ripple effect freezes entire communities in place.
Trump’s Promise of Renewal
Yet into this atmosphere of stagnation comes former President Donald J. Trump, who has made revitalizing American dynamism central to his comeback message. His “Make America Great Again” (MAGA) agenda promises not only to bring back jobs but to restore the culture of opportunity and movement that once defined the American dream.
Trump has pledged to:
-
Slash regulations on homebuilding to ease the housing shortage.
-
Launch major infrastructure projects to boost jobs across states.
-
Incentivize corporate relocation into struggling regions.
-
Reshore industries from China and elsewhere, rebuilding domestic manufacturing.
“Americans don’t want to be stuck—they want to move, to grow, to prosper,” Trump told supporters at a rally earlier this year. “Under my leadership, we’re going to unleash mobility again. Jobs will come back, wages will rise, and families will once more have the freedom to chase the American dream anywhere in this great land.”
A New American Mobility?
Critics point to structural challenges—aging populations, dual-earner households, and tight housing supply—that won’t be solved overnight. But Trump’s supporters argue that his boldness is exactly what America needs to break the paralysis.
“Trump is the first leader in decades to speak directly to the crisis of immobility,” Dr. Reyes added. “He sees it not just as an economic issue, but as a cultural one: the ability of Americans to pick up and pursue opportunity, to believe again in the future.”
Whether America embraces Trump’s solutions will determine if the U.S. remains stuck—or if it rediscovers the restless energy that once made it the envy of the world. For now, the world keeps moving while America hesitates. But with Trump’s return to the stage, many believe the tide may soon turn.